14 Complete Meals for $150 + Free Australia-Wide Delivery! Shop the Deal
Order by 8 am Monday, Wednesday, Friday (Sydney time).

Cooking 101

The History of Butter Chicken (and Why Ours Is Different)

3 June 2026 · 5 min read

Butter chicken — murgh makhani — feels ancient because it's everywhere, but it's roughly 80 years old. The dish was invented in the late 1940s at Moti Mahal in Delhi, and the origin story is suspiciously practical.

The Moti Mahal origin

Kundan Lal Gujral, the founder of Moti Mahal, had moved from Peshawar to Delhi after Partition. His tandoori chicken — already famous — would dry out by the end of service. To salvage the leftovers, the kitchen simmered the cooked tandoori in a sauce of tomato, butter, cream and kasuri methi. The dish was meant as a way to use product; it became the most-ordered dish in the restaurant.

The original sauce

Tomato puree, butter, cream, ginger-garlic paste, Kashmiri chilli, kasuri methi (dried fenugreek leaves), salt, a touch of sugar. No garam masala in the original. No yoghurt in the sauce. The tandoori chicken brought its own marinade flavour.

How restaurant versions drifted

Most restaurant butter chicken today is sweeter, redder and uses more sugar than the original. Some versions add cashew paste for thickness. Some skip the tandoor step entirely and just simmer raw chicken in the sauce. The dish you eat at a chain restaurant in Australia is usually two or three steps removed from the Moti Mahal recipe.

Why ours stays close to the original

We marinate boneless thigh in yoghurt and tandoori spices overnight, char it under high heat, then fold it into a tomato-cream sauce finished with kasuri methi and cultured butter. No cashew paste, no extra sugar, no shortcut. The result is closer to what you'd eat at Moti Mahal than to most restaurant versions in Australia.

How to recognise the real thing

Original butter chicken should taste of butter and tomato first, cream second, fenugreek third. The chicken should have visible char marks from the tandoor or grill. The colour should be deep orange-red, not bright orange. If it tastes mostly sweet, it's a restaurant interpretation, not the dish.