Cooking 101
Butter Chicken vs Tikka Masala: The Real Difference
19 May 2026 · 5 min read
Walk into ten Indian restaurants and you'll see butter chicken and chicken tikka masala side by side on the menu. They look similar — orange sauce, tender chicken, served with naan — and most diners use the names interchangeably. They are not the same dish.
Where each dish was born
Butter chicken (murgh makhani) was invented in the late 1940s at Moti Mahal in Delhi. The story goes that the kitchen had leftover tandoori chicken and a surplus of tomatoes, cream and butter — so the chef simmered the meat in the sauce to keep it from drying out. It became a Delhi institution within a decade. Chicken tikka masala, by contrast, is widely credited to a Glasgow curry house in the 1970s, reportedly improvised when a customer asked for a sauce to go with dry tandoori tikka. It is, in many ways, a British-Indian invention.
The sauce base
Butter chicken's base is tomato, butter and cream, finished with kasuri methi (dried fenugreek leaves) and a touch of honey or sugar. The flavour is rich, buttery, slightly sweet and unmistakably aromatic. Tikka masala leans on tomato, onion and yoghurt or cream, with a heavier hand on garam masala, paprika and cumin. The sauce is thicker, more rustic, and the spice profile is sharper.
The chicken itself
Both dishes start with chicken tikka — boneless thigh or breast marinated in yoghurt and spices, then roasted in a tandoor. In butter chicken, the tikka is folded into the sauce at the end; in tikka masala, the chicken is often simmered in the sauce longer, absorbing more flavour and softening into the gravy.
How to tell them apart on a menu
Butter chicken should taste of butter, cream, tomato and fenugreek — almost dessert-rich on the back palate. Tikka masala should taste savoury, smoky and spiced, with the chicken doing more of the talking. If the sauce is bright orange and tastes mostly of paprika, it is probably tikka masala. If it's deep orange-red, glossy and almost sweet, it is butter chicken.
How we cook ours
Our butter chicken follows the original Moti Mahal style — tandoori-marinated thigh, slow-simmered in a tomato-cream base, finished with kasuri methi and a knob of cultured butter. We don't make a tikka masala because, honestly, butter chicken is the dish we believe in. Chilled, never frozen, Halal-certified, delivered Australia-wide.
